What Young Writers Need (Blog #5)

We're living in a time where students are turning in less and less writing and doing less and less reading. This comes down to a multitude of different things that negatively affects a young person's ideology of reading and writing. One thing that directly affects writing is feedback.

Feedback on students' writings can come from a numerous number of people with varying levels of the understanding of writing. All forms of feedback directly affect the student's outlook on writing and can have either a negative or positive impact on them. We'll start with the first thing people would think of when it comes to feedback... Teachers
Teachers can have a profound impact on students' writings by providing concrete feedback throughout the writing process. This doesn't mean writing a grade and notes at the end of the paper, but rather providing feedback and helping students throughout the writing process as a whole. Yes, this means from prewriting/brainstorming all the way to the "final" product. Another key in feedback that a teacher can provide is allowing students chances to correct their "final" paper for a chance to increase their final grade. In doing this, it would show students that writing is a continuous thing that is not as finite as school can make it seem to be.

Another key resource that can provide wonderful feedback to students are tutors/writing coaches

Tutors allow students to have an opportunity to get help with their writings from someone outside of their classroom. They are typically great readers/writers and can help guide students along their writing path. It is a great way for students to reach out if they aren't comfortable with their teacher or need a different approach to writing than what they're getting in the classroom. From what I've learned as being a writing coach, is that we are essential in lifting students' spirits in regards to writing. We have the opportunity to help students who believe that they are not good writers understand that we are all at different points in our writing journey. We are here to validate them and help guide them.

The final point of reflection is often overlooked or underutilized in the classroom... Peer editing

Peer review is a powerful resource that is underutilized or used incorrectly in the classroom. It is important to see what your peers think of your work because they're, usually, the most important viewpoint of the students. If a peer states they love an idea another student presents, a friendship may form or even students may learn from each other. Peer review is often used incorrectly by having students grammar check each others papers, but this is not only unfair to the students but also damaging their views on writing and review. 

Check out this LINK to see some brief bullet points on the benefits that peer review has on the classroom.

Outside of feedback it is essential for teachers to create an inclusive space that allows options for students writing. I've seen that students create more powerful works when it matters to them. If they're interested in the topic, they're more likely to participate. Take Haddix's example about this when they stated "students engaged in a variety of topics and writing genres including hip-hop music, dance, creative writing, and cartooning" (263). By creating a variety of relatable content, there was a lot more engagement. It is up to teachers to create relatable content in order to spring an interest in writing. Otherwise writing will continue to be loathed by youths, and therefore adults too.

Comments

  1. Hi Dylan! I like that you mentioned the difference between receiving notes and a grade after submitting a per compared to actually getting help along the way. Even though both might count as "feedback", it's so much more valuable to have a teacher guide you through the writing process. The relationship between student + teacher here is super important!

    ReplyDelete
  2. "Outside of feedback it is essential for teachers to create an inclusive space that allows options for students writing. I've seen that students create more powerful works when it matters to them." This is a really good point, we need to focus on what matters for the student. Alyssa

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hey Dylan,

    I appreciate that you mention tutors as a reliable yet unique source of writing assistance, as people that students may feel more comfortable reaching out to than teachers. This is an important distinction because it may feel more low-stakes coming from someone who is genuinely interested in feedback only, not assessment. Great point!

    Clare

    ReplyDelete
  4. The way you talked about the affects of peer review spoke to me. Peer review is always given as a grammar checker. However, the idea that it could influence students to open to their peers' ideas and really look at each others progress is such a better technique. The impact this can have on a classroom environment is amazing. This idea gets me very excited and I began brainstorming ways I could do that in my future classroom. Love, love, LOVE this. -- Jalousy

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hi Dylan, I like how you mentioned how peer review can either really work well in a classroom or not work at all. I find that when peer reviewing, it works best to have rules on what you can and cannot comment on. Like how Max told us to do the CATS comments or the 1 thing you liked, 1 thing you want to know more about... etc. That seems to work well for students who use peer review to correct punctuation and grammar -Krista R

    ReplyDelete
  6. Thank Dylan for voicing your views here on how "writers need writers" and how this translates to providing meaningful opportunities for peer feedback in the classroom. Your awareness of your own needs as a writer and confidence in knowing this was a part of your decisions to advocate and show up for the face-to-face peer feedback session. This hope that you will be able to translate some of this "writers need writers" advocacy to your future teaching and work with writers.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

A book trailer on Skim (Blog #7)

Rating my Blogs (Blog #8)

Welcome to my Professional Blog